Critical Mass June 21, 2023: What makes for a good SF/fantasy story? 

A few elements come to mind:  

  • Story has a beginning, middle and an end, with a resolution/catharsis  
  • Suspension of disbelief: Story/world/characters must be believable and internally consistent 
  • We care about the characters… either because they are likeable or a (macabre) curiosity as to who will survive  
  • The world is viewed through the actions of the protagonist rather than (heavy) exposition 

Do you think these elements guarantee a good SF/fantasy story? What would you add to this list? Are there SF/fantasy books you would recommend even though they don’t seem contain these elements?

Share your experiences with books that you don’t think pulled it off even though they seemed to have followed a good formula. Does a good story in fact need to follow any “formula”?

Have the requirements changed from the early days (say, 30s or 70s) SF/Fantasy?

This meeting will be zoom only

Zoom details:

Critical Mass
Time: Jun 21, 2023 6:30pm Adelaide, 7:00pm Canberra, Melbourne, Sydney

Join Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/86711562991?pwd=L0VoYjkrRlIwWU05QmxWU0tqaUZiZz09

Meeting ID: 867 1156 2991
Passcode: 535708

New Doctor Who episodes revealed…

A new Doctor Who trailer revealed episode titles for 60th Anniversary Specials.
Moments before the Eurovision Song Contest Grand Final came live from Liverpool the new Doctor Who trailer announced the titles as:  

  • Special One: The Star Beast
  • Special Two: Wild Blue Yonder
  • Special Three: The Giggle

Crit Mass, May 17th: The Inheritance Trilogy

Roman’s going to look at N K Jemisin’s Inheritance Trilogy:
The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms (2010),
The Broken Kingdoms (2010)
The Kingdom of Gods (2011)

This fantasy trilogy is set in a world where one country rules, partly due to its enslavement of several gods, giving the ruling Armari family immense power.

Yeine Darr is summoned to the magnificent floating city of Sky by her grandfather Dekarta, the ruler of the world and head of the Arameri family.

As Yeine is also Arameri, he names her his heir — but he had already assigned that role to both his niece and his nephew. Traditionally the issue is resolved by a fight to the death. Yeine seems an unlikely victor, but there are background political ploys which may work in her favour…

If you’re in Adelaide, meet at kappy’s in Compton St (near the market).
Doors open at 6:15 for a 6:30pm start.

Zoom Details:


Time: Wednesday May 17, 2023 — 6:30 Adelaide, 7:00 pm Canberra, Melbourne, Sydney

Join Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/86711562991?pwd=L0VoYjkrRlIwWU05QmxWU0tqaUZiZz09

Meeting ID: 867 1156 2991
Passcode: 535708

Time to ReConnect

ReConnect is a 2023 convention for science fiction, fantasy and horror fans and professionals in Aotearoa New Zealand and beyond.
Two+ days of panels, discussions, talks, and socializing — all online to revitalize fandom in preparation for the 2024 national convention.

The convention is running online on the weekend of June 2nd.

For more info/membership details: ReConnect

Before and After in the world of the Arameri

Shades in Shadow

Three brand new short stories set in the world of the Inheritance trilogy.

A newborn god with an old, old soul struggles to find a reason to live. A powerful demon searches for her father, and answers. And in a prequel to the Inheritance Trilogy, a newly-enslaved Nahadoth forges a dark alliance with a mortal, for survival. . . and revenge.

The Awakened Kingdom

A novella which takes place after the events in Kingdom of Gods
As the first new godling born in thousands of years — and the heir presumptive to Sieh the Trickster — Shill’s got big shoes to fill. She’s well on her way when she defies her parents and sneaks off to the mortal realm, which is no place for an impressionable young god.

Lockwood & Co. at Critical Mass this Wednesday, April 19th

Adam enjoyed the series (both as novels & TV), and is going to talk about why this Wednesday.

What could possibly go wrong in a cemetery…  Ali Hadji-Heshmati (playing George Karim), Cameron Chapman (as Anthony Lockwood) and Ruby Stokes (as Lucy Carlyle)

Lockwood & Co. is a young adult supernatural thriller series which follows three young operatives of a psychic detection agency (Lucy Carlyle, Anthony Lockwood, and George Cubbins) as they fight ghosts (known throughout the series as Visitors) in London, England. There are five novels in the series, published from 2013

If you’re in Adelaide, meet at kappy’s in Compton St (near the market).
Doors open at 6:15 for a 6:30pm start.

Zoom details:
Time: Apr 19, 2023 at 6:30 at kappy’s / 7:00 PM Canberra, Melbourne, Sydney

https://us02web.zoom.us/j/86711562991?pwd=L0VoYjkrRlIwWU05QmxWU0tqaUZiZz09

Meeting ID: 867 1156 2991
Passcode: 535708

Exploration Story Bundle

The Sci-Fi Exploration Bundle – curated by Adam Gaffen:

Exploration. It’s hardwired into humanity’s genes.

As far back into history you want to go, there have always been people who want to push the boundaries of what we know. Whether that was looking to the stars and wondering where those twinkling lights came from, or what was across that intimidating-looking ocean, or what the purpose of all that red stuff inside the human body, the questions never seemed to end.

That spirit of exploration has never stopped. It’s alive today, as we push boundaries in space, on the planet, and into the dreams of cyberspace. We’ve gathered ten notable authors to give you their takes on where humanity’s endless curiosity might take us.

— from Adam Gaffen’s description of the bundle.

Come with us as our voyage of exploration begins!

You can read more about the bundle here — the bundle is available until May 5th.

Have our tastes changed?

Some of us wonder if today’s SF fans enjoy the same sf novels as earlier SF fans.
As it turns out, there were interesting surveys taken of best SF novels in 1987 (at the British eastercon) and 2022 (a poll of the media death cult members).
SFF Concatention recently published their analysis of the comparison here.

In summary:

“the result do not show a wildly difference in SF tastes between the 1980s and 2020s generations of fans: in fact, there are similarities.  10 of the SF² Concatenation top twenty appear in of the Cult’s top 40: indeed all but one, Tiger Tiger / Stars My destination appear in the Cult’s top 30.  When it comes to authors, there is an even greater similarity: 7 in SF² Concatenation top twenty top ten cited authors appear in the Cult’s top 40. This bumps up to 8 authors if Alfred (working class) Bester, author of Tiger Tiger / Stars My destination, who was not one of the top ten most cited author but was in the mix as a lower ranking author.”the result do not show a wildly difference in SF tastes between the 1980s and 2020s generations of fans: in fat, there are similarities.  10 of the SF² Concatenation top twenty appear in of the Cult’s top 40: indeed all but one, Tiger Tiger / Stars My destination appear in the Cult’s top 30.  When it comes to authors, there is an even greater similarity: 7 in SF² Concatenation top twenty top ten cited authors appear in the Cult’s top 40. “

Best Science Fiction Novels Then and Now in SFF Concatenation

BSFA Award winners

The BSFA awards are voted on by BSFA members and, more recently, members of the British science fiction convention, Eastercon. Their aim, according to the BSFA website, is to “seek to honour the most worthy examples in each category, but also to promote the genre of science fiction, and get people reading, talking about, and enjoying all that contemporary science fiction has to offer.”

To qualify, the work must have been released in 2022.

Best Novel (defined as a work greater than 40,000 words)

  • Winner: City of Last Chances by Adrian Tchaikovsky
  • Stars and Bones by Gareth Powell
  • The Coral Bones by E.J. Swift
  • The Red Scholar’s Wake by Aliette de Bodard
  • The This by Adam Roberts

Best Short Fiction (defined as work less than 40,000 words)

  • “A Moment of Zugzwang” by Neil Williiamson
  • Luca by Or Luca
  • Winner: Of Charms, Ghosts and Grievances by Aliette de Bodard
  • Ogres by Adrian Tchaikovsky
  • “Seller’s Remorse” by Rick Danforth

Venessa Armstrong, Tor.com for details of all awards

Stargate’s Future at Amazon May Include Movies and Series

Molly Templeton at Tor.com writes:

When Amazon Studios bought the legendary movie studio MGM last year, they bought a huge catalog of movie and television properties. Obviously, they weren’t just going to sit on those new acquisitions—not when there are always remakes and reboots to create!
According to Deadline, executives have been combing through that catalog, deciding which bits of intellectual property are best suited to being further developed—and sorting out the rights to said projects.

A handful of projects have been chosen for movie or TV development—and Stargate is among them.
[…]
The future potential of Stargate has been discussed for years and years, but the last related project to come to fruition was the brief web series Stargate Origins in 2018. Before Amazon bought MGM, there was talk of a Stargate revival featuring members of the Stargate SG-1 cast. Once upon a time, there were plans for a Stargate Extinction movie.

Stargate’s Future at Amazon May Include Movies and Series